|
Apamea
By Carol
Miller* |
"The normal origin of
aristocracies:
First as conquerors, then as rulers."
Suetonius |
What do moth species and cutworms, among many lepidoptera and
virus, have to do with Alexander the Great? Where do the Pheromones
and Antoninus of Apamea converge on Alexander's Asian Empire?
Perhaps a cultivated and enterprising entomologist was inspired by
the name or, more likely, by the idyllic setting or the impassioned
history, of one of Syria's most romantic sites. For there, on the
right bank of the Orontes on the Plain of Ghaab (or Al-Ghab), about
three kilometers from the Al-Assi river, 55 kilometers from Hama, Seleukos
Nikator I, "the Victorious, the Triumphant", one of
Alexander's surviving generals elevated to the status of a reigning
monarch, built one of the most beautiful of all the Hellenistic
cities of Asia, and he named it for the lovely Apamee, or Apamea,
his Persian wife.
The
Macedonian conquest would appear to have been impeccably timed, and
served to almost magically transform Western Asia. Though far from
perfect, and definitely erratic given the disparity in the land, its
peoples, their societies and faiths, the political and cultural
infusion was such that it long outlived the successor states of
Alexander's fleeting, and fanciful, adventure, creating lasting
changes in communication, in art, literature, trade, jurisprudence,
religion and mythology, education, and what Aristotle had laid down
as the beginnings of science, but most important for a people who
loved commerce and the luxuries or novelties it provided, it made
possible a fuller economic exchange between the Asian and the
European worlds. Despite wars, insurrections, revolutions,
corruption, dissent -- all the permanent foibles of the human
condition -- the Seleucid Empire was to give the Near East an
economic order and a structure of justice - a unifying force-that
Persia had provided prior to Alexander, and which Rome would supply
after Caesar. "Harmony," says historian Will Durant,
"was enforced by the kings, and was literally worshipped by the
people as a god", thus fostering an enviable Greek world that
at least for the Macedonians - for they, themselves, were outsiders
-- idealized Greek values, but which would never again be fully
Greek.
The so-called Hellenistic years - a catch-all term that has come to
define a loose period over a vague geography, following the
repartition of Alexander's conquests among a number of his otherwise
incompatible and disharmonious generals-- were nonetheless worldly
and wealthy, and eclectic in the best sense of the term. Commerce
was the life of the economy. The river valleys, fertile then beyond
belief, produced the stuff of great fortunes. The land was
effectively irrigated by a system of canals. Bankers provided public
and private credit, so coinage replaced the barter system. Ships
were larger and faster, and overland routes more efficient. For two
of these, however, the rival Seleucid and Ptolemaic dynasties fought
the "Syrian Wars" that finally weakened them both to the
point of vulnerability in the face of the inevitable destabilizing
strategies and the ultimate military onslaught of Rome.
Until then the Seleucid monarchy, heir to the Asiatic territories
and with them their traditions, was absolute. The Court, in nearly
every aspect Oriental, was nevertheless elevated on Greek speech,
administrative order and the loyalty of the Greek population, for
which the Seleucid kings labored to restore former Greek cities and
to establish new ones. Seleucos I founded nine Seleucias, six
Antiochs, five Laodiceas, three Apameas, one Stratonice.
The Hellenistic infiltration was therefore a Renaissance of sorts,
described by historians (see: Graham Shipley, The Greek World
After Alexander, 323-30 B.C., London, Routledge, 2000) as one of
the most fruitful and surprising of ancient history. "No change
so swift nor so far-reaching had ever been seen in Asia," says
Amelie Kuhrt. This vigorous, imaginative and definitely resourceful
culture was full of variety, refinement and intensity. It was
especially rich in art and learning. Yet with all of this,
"Greek intellect made no entry into the Oriental mind,"
continues Will Durant, "so beyond the Mediterranean coast the
Greek veneer grew thin, as at Seleucia-on-the-Tigris or Doura
Europos on the Euphrates. There was no such fusion of races and
cultures as Alexander had envisioned." For all practical
purposes the Greeks accepted the Oriental deities, the East
insinuated its fatalism into Greek philosophy, and all the while the
Syrian cults - opulent, pleasurable, obsessive, succulent--
proceeded to enthrall the invading Macedonians. "The Greeks
offered the East philosophy, the East offered Greece religion;
religion, the more imperative of the two, became in the end
triumphant."
At the beginning of Seleucos' reign Syria stretched from the Arabian
Gulf to the Black Sea, from the Bosporus to the Tigris and
Euphrates, and while these territories gradually shrank over the
years, because of dispute and dissention, the core of the empire
remained in the Orontes valley, with its tall grasses for the
pasturing of a million horses. According to Roman geographer and
historian Strabo, "Here the colt-breakers, hoplite trainers,
and all the other educationalists in military matters drew their
salaries." Seleucos, he says, owned 300 stallions, 30,000 mares
and 500 elephants trained for combat. The commercially successful
crossroads on the broad plain of Ghaab became crucial to the
empire's Mediterranean dominions. Apamea, along with Antiochia,
Seleucia and Laodicea - the Tetropolis -- was by this time
considered one of the four most important cities in the region, in
effect the power base of the Seleucids in Syria.
The
settling of Apamea was by no means arbitrary. Archaeological
discoveries verify early habitation, even to the extent of a
workshop for the production of flints during the Paleolithic. An
agrarian settlement occupied the site during the Neolithic, making
it contemporary to Chatal Huyuk in central Anatolia, and to the same
degree devoted to the figure of the Earth Mother. Scrapers, knives
and scythes have been unearthed, indicating continuity of habitation
until the Bronze Age. The first real community, however, with its
orchards, grapevines, and great flocks of sheep, was possibly
founded, according to Hittite texts, by Arkoulini, king of Hama.
The valley came to be called Urhilina during the ninth century B.C.
It was described as Niya in an Egyptian account of an expedition by
Amenhotep. It was known as Pharanke (or Pharneke) during a period of
Persian influence under the Al Furs Empire during the fifth century
B.C. When Eskandar al-Makdouni (Alexander the Great) occupied Syria
after the battle of Issus in 333 B.C. he named it Pella, in memory
of his Macedonian birthplace. He, like all the others, perceived the
potential in the lovely setting.
According to Strabo, "there was an acropolis, mostly
well-defended, for it is a well-fortified hill in a hollow plain.
The Orontes makes it like a peninsula, as does a large lake lying
round it which discharges itself into wide marshes and exceedingly
large meadows for oxen and horses. And thus the city is securely
located…and it enjoys an extensive and blessed land through which
the Orontes flows and dependent towns occur frequently in it."
The original site of Seleucos' acropolis - by this time called
Apamea, Afamia, Euphemia or Femie -- was atop the eastern slope of
the hill that rises above what later came to be the Ottoman khan,
and until the sixteenth century when it was called Al-Madiq, or Al
Naher al-Makhloub, it was still referred to as the Apamea Citadel.
Seleucos expanded his new Apamea in 331 B.C., down the western face
of the Alzawieh Mountain until it spilled across the plain, to an
eventual urban plan of 250 hectares, with agora, theater, temples,
baths, palaces, villas, fountains, public buildings and, joining
them all, the spectacular colonnaded Cardo Maximus, that stretches
to a vanishing point among the green fields and the red poppies in
the distance.
Because Numenius of Apamea was born here, the city became the center
of the Neoplatonic school of philosophy, indulged during the reign
of Iamblichos. This late second century B.C. Greek philosopher who
with Maximus of Tyre was responsible for the transition from
Platonist idealism to Neoplatonic synthesis, managed to bridge the
Hellenistic, Persian and Jewish intellectual systems, to reaffirm,
in his words, that "matter and God are inherently
separate". In other times this might have seemed a heresy of
sorts, but philosophers in Apamea were treated with infinite
indulgence. "Matter," he insisted, "was evil and
negative, a hindrance to the spirit." So it was a dual figure,
a demigod or Demiurge, he said, who was responsible for the
Creation. None of this deterred Poseidonius of Apamea (135-50 B.C.).
The celebrated Greek philosopher, astronomer and mathematician, a
student of Panaetius, developed a new Stoic tradition of ethics and
carried it to Rhodes, where it flourished until his death. Oppianus
of Apamea also brought fame to the city with his poetry, prose and
drama.
Apamea's jurisdiction ultimately grew until it filled the entire
valley, finally encompassing an area as large as 600 square
kilometers. About one hundred years after the founding of the
Hellenistic city, however, under constant threat of Persian
invasion, its urban core came to be enclosed by trapezoidal walls,
with well over fifty towers, all now ruined, and four monumental
gates, around the six kilometers of the city perimeter.
Apamea was especially propitious as a military base, with its rich
pastureland for the horses and elephants, and the school for the
training of the war elephants brought, along with their mahouts, or
handlers, from India. It seems Seleucos had personally traded them
for land he was in any case ill-equipped to administer, territories
that straddled the legendary Gandhara region in what today lies
along the border between Pakistan and Afghanistan. The elephants
were in fact revered. An elephant adorned one of Apamea's coins, and
the best and bravest of the great beasts, for distinction in battle,
was awarded a silver "Medal of Merit".
Apamea's military role continued into the Roman era, that began with
the conquest of Syria by Pompey (64-63 B.C.), and the designation of
the Syrian Province. In the first century B.C. the satirical poet
"Juvenal" (Decimus Junius Juvenalis) wrote: "The
Syrian Orontes now flows into the Tiber, bringing its language and
customs." Though an earthquake practically leveled Apamea in
115 A.D., because of its cultural, commercial and military
importance Hadrian, by this time emperor, ordered it rebuilt.
Apamea served as the winter quarters for the Second Legion.
Inscribed in Latin in memory of the soldiers of the Parthian unit
formed by Septimus Severus were one hundred and ten headstones,
discovered by archaeologists in one of the eastern towers. A peace
agreement between Rome and Persia in 162 A.D., however, required the
slaughter of the elephant battalion, a very unpopular demand.
By the end of the third century Diocletian had divided Syria into
five separate Roman provinces. The region, densely populated despite
the gradual expiring of the local dynasties, remained prosperous,
producing an abundance of corn and olives. "Syria is the
granary of the empire," it was said in Rome, "and is just
as rich in the literary and the artistic."
After the Edict of Constantine, Apamea was further enriched by a
number of churches, and assumed as well an important role in the
conversion of the local population. Perhaps the early Earth Mother
cult lent itself to the worship of the Virgin Mother. Yet by virtue
of these ramified roots, a number of other, singular, cults emerged.
St. Julian of Apamea, a third century bishop, appointed himself the
most stalwart opponent of Montanism, an ecstatic prophetic movement
named after its founder, Montanus (c. 170 A.D.). It was known until
the fourth century as the "Phrygian heresy", from its
place of origin and greatest source of support. Montanist prophets,
in apparent anticipation of Sufism, claimed direct oracular
revelations from God, in support of their teachings on the ecstatic
nature of prophesying, on eschatology, and on asceticism.
Polychronius, from Antioch, was Bishop of Apamea until his death in
430, and according to his writings, struggled constantly against the
inherent conflict "in the proliferation of new heresies, in
which every man has his own theology." Introverted asceticism,
he claimed, "vied with theatrical severities." He advised
instead to till the fields, which he considered "an excellent
prayer."
Markellos (Marcellus) of Apamea was a fourth century Cyprus-born
bishop, who "pursued idol-worshippers", wrecking and
burning their temples and altars. The "pagans" ultimately
consigned him to the flames that, it was said, he himself had
created, "by calling down divine intervention onto the Temple
of Zeus Belos", and so, wrote the Christian historians of the
day, "he died as a martyr for Christ." The controversy
nevertheless continued, while the "pagans" argued that the
Christians, in their veneration of the saints, were as much
idol-worshipers as anyone else.
Apamea, with a high ranking among Syria's bishoprics, ultimately
became a center for Monophysitism, an endless harangue on the
Christian myth. Was Jesus human or divine? If he was human he
suffered. Was this suffering warranted? And if he was divine, he was
resurrected. Or was he? The adherence to a "one nature"
Christology lured dogmatists for generations, while the debate
ramified into dozens of sects. One of these, the Nestorians,
proliferated throughout Byzantium and meantime the Eastern
Christians -- Coptic, Jacobite, Armenian, Nubian and Ethiopian
-opposed the brand of Christology expounded by the Council of
Chalcedon. This led the Prophet, Mohammed himself, to debate the
point, and thus the sacred Koran begins with an often-mistranslated
phrase. The customary "There is no God but Allah…" is
supposed to read: "There is no god but God".
"Allah" in any case means "God" in Arabic, so
instead of the redundancy the intention was a clarification: Jesus
Christ is a prophet but he is not God. Only God is God. God may be
called by any name, in any language, Yehovah, Mazda, Allah, but He
is One, and One Alone.
Christian debate and disunity, surrounding the same subject,
continued until the resurgence of the Persian invasions, in the
sixth century A.D. Apamea resisted a siege by Chosroes I in 540 but
succumbed in 573, until the emperor Heraclios recovered the city for
the Byzantines, between 613 and 628, a condition he was able to
maintain until the advent of Islam. With the Arab invasion, headed
by Abi Obeida Ibn el-Jarah, Apamea preferred to surrender
peacefully, in 638. The commercial importance of the site, however,
and its strategic location, caused the Byzantines, in 975, to renew
their struggle to regain it.
Apamea remained peaceably in Byzantine hands for eighteen years.
Then in 1106 the city was overwhelmed by the Crusader Tancred, who
brought it under the jurisdiction of the Principality of Antioch.
Nur ad-din Mahmoud ibn Zanki, known through history as the great
Nuradin -- one of the most compelling of all Muslin leaders, and
mentor of Saladin who followed him -- took the citadel hill back
from the crusaders in 1149.
Not long afterward, in 1157, and again in 1170, catastrophic
earthquakes shook northern Syria and destroyed Apamea, along with
Hama, the nearby citadel of Shaizar, Homs (Emesa) and Antioch, among
other key sites. Except for a small handful, the resolute who
refused to abandon their homes, most of the population fled from the
valley. Nuradin rebuilt the fortress on the citadel hill in 1158, a
labor that continued during the Ayyubid and Mamluk periods, still
conserving the name of Apamea, but the city below was left in ruins,
to be visited only by the occasional scholar or traveler, who might
be inspired to produce monographs on its history or odes to its
sweet, verdant beauty, the butterflies among the fallen columns, the
dragonflies, the lizards and frogs.
In 1928 the Fondation Nationale de Recherce Scientifique of
Bruselles began a series of archaeological studies, including
mapping and excavations, which continued in 1930-8, 1947, 1965 and
1992. Their labors determined that the Greeks, making good use of
the essentially flat valley floor, had adopted a grid pattern city
plan. The main street, completed under Marcus Aurelius (161-180)
stretched from the Antioch Gate at its north end for about two
kilometers, straight as an arrow to the southern gate. As opposed to
the colonnaded main street at Palmyra, to which the camel caravans
had access, the avenue at Apamea was paved. Fifteen cross streets
intersected it from east to west. Gigantic columns ten meters high
lined the street on either side, each column placed at three meters
from the other, in all 1200 columns. Porticoes, as to the Assembly
Hall, were also decorated with columns, using a variety of design
motifs. Most noteworthy is the spiral, or fluted design, for which
the columns in Apamea are justifiably celebrated, but others were
square or circular, topped by Hellenistic capitals, the architraves
graced by sculptures of city leaders embraced by garlands in a
delicate pattern of exquisite foliage.
The rectangular plaza, with its shops, shaded arcades and stalls in
a concentration of all daily activities, was considered an essential
element of city planning. The Apamea plaza - the forum or agora
-- was located near the Cardo Maximus in the center of the city, and
probably dates from Hadrian's reign (117-138). It measured 150 by 25
meters and was adorned with columns of varied design.
The theater was also a fundamental characteristic of any Hellenistic
city, a custom inherited from Classical Greece that continued into
the Roman era. Greek theaters were backed up against a hill - as
opposed to the free-standing Roman theaters-and Apamea's, dating
from the second century, was reinforced in the acropolis mound. It
was nevertheless modified under the Romans, to become one of the
largest on record, with a diameter of 135 meters. Its ruined state
is attributed, more than to earthquake, to the fact of the stones
being ransacked for the rebuilding of the citadel, which was itself
destroyed by earthquake.
The stones were cannibalized again to build the Ottoman khan under
order of Suleiman the Magnificent in the sixteenth century, to house
merchants and pilgrims on their travels between Istanbul and Anadoul
on the Antioch road. Located to the south of the Al-Madiq citadel,
226 meters above sea level, the square plaza measures 80 by 80
meters. A large courtyard in the center looks straight up at the
citadel's colossal retaining walls, and was surrounded by a number
of vaulted rooms, all confected of the recycled stone brought block
by block down the hill. A small traveler's mosque, also from the
Ottoman period, stands on a slope just above the khan, under the
citadel walls.
Though grown shabby over the years, the khan was nonetheless rescued
and rebuilt, and since 1982 has served very well, within its
limitations and with poor lighting, as the on-site archaeological
museum. It is especially famous for its extraordinary mosaics, too
many, it seems, to display them all. Mosaic art, originated in Egypt
and Mesopotamia, was eventually taken over by the Greeks, who lifted
it to its apogee. This propitiated its continuation in the
Hellenistic, Roman and Byzantine worlds, and by association, well
into the art of the early Umayyad period. The desired painting was
"quadriculated", that is, divided by a grid into small
square units. Scraps of stone, usually marble, granite or alabaster
(a young marble), of varied colors, were then assembled to reproduce
the painting, in all its detail and nuances of light and shadow
-definitely an art of its own - that lent itself to application as a
flooring material, able to survive the treading of millions of
footsteps. A masterpiece composition could contain as many as a
million and a half stone fragments, averaging two to three
millimeters square. The Apamea mosaics, by contrast with the
pictorial compositions found elsewhere, for example, in Shahba or
Antioch, tended to representations of nature: idyllic scenes of
ducks and partridges, a large waterwheel, lions pursuing an oryx, a
soldier leading his horse through an enchanted garden, a camel
convoy, deer in the forest.
Museum displays include as well the obelisks and columns from one of
the towers in the wall, along with Greek and Latin obelisks,
discovered in the necropolis outside the city's limits, adjacent to
the wall. Sarcophaguses from the second century, intricately carved
and mostly of local gypsum, describe the devotion of a mate to her
spouse, skill in battle, wisdom in public administration. One such
sarcophagus, with a crown carried by angels, was found on the Cardo
Maximus. Since the necropolis had long since been plundered it was
assumed by the Belgian archaeologists that the lovely marble
sculpture had been reduced to serving as a deposit for rainwater. As
for the tombs, they were constructed in layers in towers, or, on the
contrary, were arranged in neat rows of crypts in a subterranean
format, or hypogeum. Rock tombs were not unknown.
The richly decorated and harmoniously designed temples were the
signature structures of the site; they bridged the Hellenistic
regime into the Roman period. A grapevine motif adorned the Temple
of Bacchus and was easily identified by the archaeological team. All
that remains of the Temple of Zeus Belos, however, after Marcellus'
destruction in 384-385 in his attempt to exorcize idolatry, are the
foundation walls.
Public baths became especially fashionable during the Roman period
and the custom spread throughout Syria. The central section (Tepidarium)
and inner hot tubs (Caldarium) are all that survive but they are
still visible to one side of the main street.
Aerial photogrammetry revealed the route of the water channels, and
subsequent excavations were able to unearth and reassemble the
square pillars that supported the arches of the aqueducts. A tunnel
system further distributed water through limestone ducts, 90
centimeters in diameter, with an inside diameter of 45 centimeters.
Pottery water pipes with a diameter of 25-30 centimeters, of the
sort still in use inside the souks in Aleppo, branched out from the
main channels. The water came from a number of sources, some as
nearby as three kilometers, another that drained from the citadel
hill and, eighty kilometers distant, the main source in Al-Salamieh
or Salimiye, still in use today.
Domestic architecture was less spectacular than the public buildings
and was generally uniform, actually quite rustic and unpretentious,
with a stone façade and a modestly decorated portico, that led to a
square inner courtyard. Reception and dining areas occupied the
ground floor. The demand for housing grew as people gravitated to
the city from the surrounding countryside. The palaces, on the other
hand, in which the ruling class lived and entertained, were quite
grand, and competed for the most elaborate mosaics.
The most important Christian ruin discovered to date, with its huge
façade composed of three columns on the order of the Basilica to
St. Simeon (Qalaat Samaan) near Aleppo, is the Cathedral, on a
typically Byzantine cross plan, with rich ornamentation and a number
of mosaics. An inscription confirms the consecration of an earlier
church, or martyrium, as the cathedral -- destined to house a Holy
Cross, later vanished -- in 535 A.D. The cross was reputed to have
come from Jerusalem after the sacking and burning of the Holy
Sepulchre, but this was never confirmed. A number of the Apamea
churches were documented in Constantine's lists of 536, thus
providing a clue to the excavations, in the badly damaged
archaeological remains.
Many of the fallen columns have been set upright. Others remain
tossed and broken in the grass. Buildings have collapsed. A part of
Apamea's history is buried with the stones. But nothing can dim the
perfume of the flowers or the hum of the bees in the wheat that
grows for the farmers in the valley, who cultivate around the ruins.
Cows graze where the elephants once fed, knee-deep in the rich
fields. Goats carouse in the ruined churches. A motorcycle careens
along the uneven stones of the Cardo Maximus. Two laughing children
cling to their father as he bounces them along, sharing their glee.
So ends the greed and the glory of an era unlike any other. Apamea
today is no more than a moth or a cutworm, in the catalog of a
lepidopterist.
Carol Miller
is a sculptress and writer, devoted to her avid research of ancient
cultures, from Mexico where she lives, or along her travels
throughout the world. "Mari" is a chapter from a
forthcoming book, soon to be available at Amazon.com or
BarnesandNoble.com. Among her titles are "The Winged Prophet,
from Hermes to Quetzalcoatl", with Guadalupe Rivera Marin, a
study in comparative mythology; and "Travels in the Maya
World", "The Other Side of Yesterday, the China-Maya
Connection" and "Training Juan Domingo: Mexico and
Me", exerpts of which can be viewed at http://www.xlibris.com/CarolMiller.html |
|